Lecture 5: Joyce's Response
Joyce Fortune
About Joyce
Dr Joyce Fortune is a senior lecturer and Head of the Technology Management Department at the Open University. Her teaching and research interests include systems failures, quality management and technology strategy. Her latest book is about learning from information system failures. Other topics she has written about recently include risk in project management, the cultural school of strategy formation and human rights and ethical policing.
In the forum
You've heard the lectures. You've seen what our experts have to say. But what do you think? It's time for you to join the debate.
Our experts' views
'Global warming and nuclear emissions know no boundaries'
Joyce Fortune
'Technology cannot make us less profligate'
Derek Matravers
'Suddenly, Lord Broers is less gung-ho about technology'
Tom Hewitt
Nick Braithwaite
As someone who has spent over twenty years developing methods for the investigation of failures and teaching others how to learn from them I was pleased to see Lord Broers drawing on the sinking of the Titanic at the start of his lecture. As I read on, however, I did begin to think that Chernobyl might have been a more apposite starting point.
In the early hours of Saturday 26 April 1986, two explosions destroyed the core of the Unit 4 reactor and the roof of the reactor building at the Chernobyl nuclear plant in Ukraine. A plume of smoke, radioactive fission products and debris rose about one km into the air. Some of it fell back to the ground but the remainder began its journey around the northern hemisphere and was joined, not long after, by emissions from a graphite fire that raged for the next ten days. 31 firemen died as a result of the radiation doses they received and the wider death toll from the accident still continues to rise slowly but, according to the most authoritative source (the World Health Organisation), is relatively modest.
If the sinking of the Titanic was a failure of technology it was a closely bounded one. Global warming and nuclear emissions know no such boundaries.
In the early hours of Saturday 26 April 1986, two explosions destroyed the core of the Unit 4 reactor and the roof of the reactor building at the Chernobyl nuclear plant in Ukraine. A plume of smoke, radioactive fission products and debris rose about one km into the air. Some of it fell back to the ground but the remainder began its journey around the northern hemisphere and was joined, not long after, by emissions from a graphite fire that raged for the next ten days. 31 firemen died as a result of the radiation doses they received and the wider death toll from the accident still continues to rise slowly but, according to the most authoritative source (the World Health Organisation), is relatively modest.
If the sinking of the Titanic was a failure of technology it was a closely bounded one. Global warming and nuclear emissions know no such boundaries.
Bookmark with:
Comments
Please wait while loading. You must have JavaScript enabled to view comments.
