go to openscience go to BBC Online go to the OU
return to Masters of Science homepage
go to Open2.NET
go to Janet's homepage go to Katherine's homepage go to Charles' homepage Discussion Topic
Should we use genetically modified pigs to produce body parts for human transplants?

HUGH DEVLIN
14/08/01

I don't think this will be an issue in the near future as scientists are looking at cloning body parts i.e. taking the DNA out of a cell from a patient that may need a replacement heart, putting that DNA into a empty embryo and growing it until you can extract the stem cells which can be turned into any cell in the body thus preventing rejection of the transplant. One day we may have replacement limbs so I see no problem in genetics for the good and well being of mankind. Fortunately or unfortunately there is always two sides to the coin but if there was not, I think we would still be in caves or up trees, that's progress.

ROBRUS
7/11/01

I think as I and the general public have no real concept as to the affects of genetic tinkering, we would be foolish to accept any form of treatment being sold to us which had not been thoroughly researched by scientific establishments that did not stand to make a profit, that's providing one exists. My other point is this, if the evolution of the human race up to this point has bean left to chance, and the reproductive selection system which nature has already provided is now being replaced by something more palatable as far as humans are concerned, does this mean that genetic tinkering can be seen as an evolutionary step up the ladder for humankind or is this bacon sandwich I am eating right now the only reason for the existence of pigs, or is Adam's leap from ignorance dependant upon a genetically modified pig. My answer to the question is, what are we waiting for? get on with it, we are dead a long time.
PREVIOUS TOPICS  

go to foot and mouth discussion page

FOOT AND MOUTH
go to space tourism discussion page SPACE TOURISM
What's the current hot topic in science.? We want to hear from you, so email us at mastersofscience@bbc.co.uk with your comments, which will appear on this site.


   
Go to the Masters of Science website at the Open University
join our discussion
join our activities
return to Masters of Science homepage